He's too consistent to be an All-Star,as terrible as that is to say. He's consistently very, very good. He's not a breakout hitter and he doesn't really go through many slumps or surges. And as great as he is in right, you don't generally think of the right fielder as a particularly talented defender, whether he is one or not. As awful as it is, those things don't necessarily add up to an All-Star. Not in the traditional way. Throw in the fact that he played for a perennial loser for the first half of his career and that Baltimore is a relatively small market, and you get Markakis being left off of all those teams.